← Back to blog
Training· 5 min read

Is Junk Volume Real? What the Research Says

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

Junk volume is real, but it is narrower than the internet suggests. Sets stopped far from failure add little growth, and very long sessions show diminishing returns per set. Hard sets within about 1-3 reps of failure, spread across the week at roughly 10-20 sets per muscle, are rarely junk.

Yes, junk volume exists. But most people use the term wrong. It does not mean any set past a magic number. It means sets that cost you time and fatigue without adding much growth. There are two main kinds: sets that are too easy to count, and sets piled so deep into one session that their quality falls apart.

What is junk volume, exactly?

Junk volume is training that adds fatigue but little extra muscle or strength. The idea comes from coaching, not a lab, so there is no official definition. Research does point to the situations where extra sets stop paying off.

  • Sets stopped well short of failure, such as 10 easy reps when you could do 20.
  • Late sets in a very long session, when fatigue has dropped your load and focus.
  • Redundant exercises that hit the same muscle in the same way, one after another.
  • Weekly volume so high that you cannot recover before the next session.

Notice what is missing from that list. A set is not junk just because it is your 15th set of the week for a muscle. The question is always whether that set was hard enough, fresh enough and different enough to add something. If it was, it probably counts.

Do more sets always build more muscle?

Up to a point, more sets usually means more growth. A 2017 meta-analysis by Schoenfeld and colleagues found each extra weekly set was linked to about 0.37% more growth, with 10 or more weekly sets per muscle producing 9.8% growth versus 5.4% for fewer than 5.

A 2019 study by Schoenfeld and colleagues put trained men on 1, 3 or 5 sets per exercise, three times a week, for 8 weeks. Muscle growth rose with volume at several sites. Strength did not. All three groups gained similar strength. So for strength, much of the extra volume added nothing measurable.

That second point matters. Whether a set is junk depends on your goal. A set that adds a little muscle may be wasted for someone chasing a stronger 1-rep max.

Is there a limit to how many sets you should do in one session?

There seems to be. A 2020 meta-analysis by Benito and colleagues looked at 111 studies of men doing resistance training. Sets per workout was the only training variable linked to growth, and the link was negative. The average was about 16 sets per session, and the authors suggested very high numbers of sets per session could reduce gains.

This was a comparison across different studies, not a direct trial, so it cannot prove cause. It does fit what lifters notice. By the 20th set of a session, your loads drop, your form fades and you are just getting tired.

The fix is simple. Spread your weekly sets across more sessions. Twenty sets for chest done as 10 on Monday and 10 on Thursday will likely beat 20 sets jammed into one long workout.

Do easy sets count toward muscle growth?

Barely. This is the most common source of junk volume. A 2024 analysis by Robinson and colleagues estimated how close to failure sets were across many studies. Muscle growth improved as sets ended closer to failure. Strength gains were similar across a wide range of effort.

You do not need to hit failure on every set, though. A 2023 meta-analysis by Refalo and colleagues found no clear growth advantage for training to absolute failure versus stopping short. The useful zone is somewhere around 0-3 reps left in the tank. Sets that end with 6 or more reps left contribute less.

Can too much fatigue in a set waste your effort?

For some goals, yes. A 2017 study by Pareja-Blanco and colleagues had two groups squat with different amounts of slowdown allowed in each set. The group stopping at 20% velocity loss did 40% fewer reps but gained similar squat strength and more jump height than the group grinding to 40% loss. The 40% group did gain more size in parts of the quads.

So grinding reps is not junk if your goal is size. If your goal is strength or power, much of that grinding is extra fatigue with no return.

How do you know if your training has junk volume?

Look for these signs in your logs and your body.

  • Your loads drop sharply across sets of the same exercise, then drop again on the next one.
  • You finish sessions longer than 90 minutes regularly and the last half feels like going through the motions.
  • Most of your sets end with you feeling you could do many more reps.
  • You are sore for days and your main lifts have stalled for several weeks.
  • You do three or four similar exercises in a row for the same muscle.

If a few of these apply, cut sets before adding anything. Drop the last exercise for each muscle, push the remaining sets a little harder, and see if your lifts start moving again within 2-3 weeks.

How much volume should you actually do?

For most people, about 10-20 hard sets per muscle per week, split over two or more sessions, is a sensible range. Beginners grow well near the bottom of that range. Advanced lifters may tolerate more, but should add volume slowly and only while recovery holds up. Research is clearest that 10 or more weekly sets beats very low volumes. Above about 20, the evidence thins out and individual recovery matters more.

Structure keeps volume honest. The MBM app is launching soon with structured programs that set weekly sets per muscle, so extra sets are a deliberate choice rather than habit.

Common questions

Are warm-up sets junk volume?

No. Warm-up sets prepare your joints and practise the movement, so they have a job. They just should not count toward your weekly working sets.

Is high-rep training junk volume?

Not if you take the sets close to failure. Light loads can build muscle well when the effort is high. High-rep sets become junk when they end with lots of reps left.

Do drop sets and supersets add junk volume?

They can save time and still be effective if each part is hard. They become junk when they replace heavier work you need for strength, or when fatigue makes every set sloppy.

Does junk volume make you lose muscle?

Not directly. The main cost is wasted time and extra fatigue, which can hurt the quality of your next sessions and slow progress over weeks.

Sources

  1. Schoenfeld et al. (2017), Journal of Sports Sciences - Weekly training volume and muscle mass
  2. Schoenfeld et al. (2019), Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise - Training volume, hypertrophy and strength in trained men
  3. Benito et al. (2020), IJERPH - Meta-analysis of resistance training on whole-body muscle growth in men
  4. Robinson et al. (2024), Sports Medicine - Proximity to failure, strength gain and muscle hypertrophy
  5. Refalo et al. (2023), Sports Medicine - Proximity-to-failure and muscle hypertrophy
  6. Pareja-Blanco et al. (2017), Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports - Velocity loss during resistance training
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog