← Back to blog
Training· 5 min read

Should You Lift Heavy When Cutting?

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

Yes. Keep your main lifts in the same moderate to heavy range you used before the cut, roughly 70-80% of your max for most sets, and keep taking sets close to failure. Do not switch to light weights for toning. Hold your volume steady unless recovery clearly suffers.

Yes, you should keep lifting heavy when you cut. The training that built your muscle is the training that keeps it. Switching to light weights and high reps to get toned is a myth. Your diet removes the fat. Your lifting tells your body the muscle underneath is still needed.

Why does lifting heavy matter more in a deficit?

When you eat less than you burn, your body looks for tissue it can spare. Muscle is expensive to keep, so if you stop giving it a reason to stay, some of it goes. The ISSN position stand on diets and body composition describes resistance training as having an impressive ability to preserve muscle, even on very low calorie diets.

Strength also holds up better than people expect. A meta-analysis by Murphy and Koehler (2022) found that people lifting in an energy deficit gained less lean mass than those at maintenance, but their strength gains were similar. A deficit makes it harder to build muscle. It does not stop you getting or staying strong if you keep training hard.

How heavy is heavy enough when cutting?

Heavy does not mean maxing out every session. Recommendations for natural bodybuilders preparing for a contest by Helms and colleagues (2015) give a useful template during a diet:

  • Train each muscle group at least twice a week.
  • Use about 3-15 reps per set, with most sets in the 6-12 range.
  • Use loads of about 70-80% of your one-rep max for most work.
  • Rest 1-3 minutes between sets.
  • Do roughly 40-70 reps per muscle group per session.

For most people that means keeping squats, presses, rows and deadlift variations in the 5-10 rep range with weights that feel hard by the last few reps, then using lighter accessory work for higher reps.

A simple upper body day on a cut might look like this:

  • Bench press: 3 sets of 5-8 reps, 2-3 minutes rest
  • Chest-supported row: 3 sets of 6-10 reps
  • Overhead press: 2-3 sets of 6-10 reps
  • Lat pulldown: 2-3 sets of 8-12 reps
  • Arms or rear delts: 2 sets of 10-15 reps, close to failure

Track the weight and reps on each lift. If you are matching last week's numbers, your training is doing its job, even if you are not adding weight.

Do light weights work just as well for keeping muscle?

Lighter weights can work if you push them hard enough. A randomised crossover trial by Carlson and colleagues (2023) put 130 trained people on a calorie-restricted diet for four weeks, once training at about 80% of their max and once at about 60%, with every set taken to momentary failure. Fat loss was similar in both conditions, and lean mass and strength were maintained in both.

Outside a deficit, a meta-analysis by Schoenfeld and colleagues (2017) found similar muscle growth across light and heavy loads, but significantly greater strength gains with loads above 60% of max. The catch with light weights is effort. Sets of 20-30 reps have to go very close to failure to count, which is unpleasant when you are hungry and tired. Heavier sets get you to a hard effort in fewer reps. That is why moderate to heavy loads stay the default for most people on a cut.

Should you cut training volume when you diet?

Not by default. A review by Roth, Schoenfeld and Behringer (2022) found studies with 10 or more weekly sets per muscle group showed low to no lean mass loss during calorie restriction. The authors warned that reducing volume during a diet may hurt muscle retention in trained people and said volume should not necessarily be reduced during long diets.

More volume is not automatically better either. In a follow-up trial, Roth and colleagues (2023) gave 38 trained men 5 sets or 3 sets per exercise during six weeks at 30 kcal per kg of body weight, with protein fixed at 2.8 g per kg of fat-free mass. Both groups lost some lean mass, with no difference between them. Both groups also kept adding load over time.

So keep doing roughly what you were doing. If recovery falls apart late in a diet, trim accessory sets before you touch the heavy compound work.

How do you keep lifting heavy safely on low energy?

Fatigue builds as a cut goes on, so a few adjustments help you stay heavy without getting hurt:

  • Leave 1-3 reps in reserve on heavy compound sets instead of grinding to failure.
  • Keep your warm-up sets. Do not skip them to save time.
  • Put your hardest lift first in the session, when you are freshest.
  • Eat some carbohydrate in the meal before training so you have fuel for your hardest sets.
  • Keep protein high, about 2.3-3.1 g per kg of lean body mass per day according to the ISSN position stand.

Form tends to slip when you are tired. The MBM app, launching soon, includes structured programs and Move IQ, which uses your phone camera to count reps and flag reps that miss range, so you can see when tired sets start getting short.

What if your lifts start going down?

Small dips late in a diet are common, especially when you get lean. Being lighter can also change your mechanics on lifts like the bench press, because there is less body mass under the bar. The goal on a cut is to hold your loads, not to set personal bests. If strength falls steadily for two or more weeks, check sleep, protein and how fast you are losing weight before blaming the program. A loss faster than about 1% of body weight per week is a common culprit.

Common questions

Is high reps better for fat loss?

No. Fat loss comes from your energy balance. High-rep training burns a little more per session, but the difference is small compared to your diet, and it gives your muscles a weaker signal unless sets go very close to failure.

Should beginners lift heavy on a cut?

Beginners should lift challenging weights with good technique, building up over weeks. A beginner's heavy might be 8-12 hard reps. One-rep max testing is not needed.

Can I do powerlifting-style training while cutting?

Yes, as long as you also get enough total sets per muscle. Very low-rep, low-volume programs may not give enough volume to protect muscle for everyone, so add some 6-12 rep accessory work.

Sources

  1. Helms et al. (2015), J Sports Med Phys Fitness - Recommendations for natural bodybuilding contest preparation: resistance and cardiovascular training
  2. Carlson et al. (2023), Res Q Exerc Sport - The effects of training load during dietary intervention upon fat loss: a randomized crossover trial
  3. Roth, Schoenfeld & Behringer (2022), Eur J Appl Physiol - Lean mass sparing in resistance-trained athletes during caloric restriction
  4. Roth et al. (2023), Scand J Med Sci Sports - Resistance training volume does not influence lean mass preservation during energy restriction in trained males
  5. Murphy & Koehler (2022), Scand J Med Sci Sports - Energy deficiency impairs resistance training gains in lean mass but not strength
  6. Schoenfeld et al. (2017), J Strength Cond Res - Strength and hypertrophy adaptations between low- vs. high-load resistance training
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog