← Back to blog
Training· 5 min read

PPL vs Upper/Lower vs Full Body: Which Split Is Best?

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

None of the three wins on muscle growth when weekly volume is equal. A 2024 meta-analysis of 14 studies found split and full-body routines produced similar strength and size. Pick by schedule: full body for 2-3 days a week, upper/lower for 4 days, and push/pull/legs for 5-6 days.

People argue about splits like it is a religion. The research is calmer. If you do the same number of hard sets per muscle each week, push/pull/legs, upper/lower and full body give you about the same result. The real question is which one fits your week, and which one you will still be running in six months.

What does the research say about split vs full body?

A 2024 meta-analysis pooled 14 studies with 392 people. Bench press strength, leg strength, arm and thigh muscle size and lean mass all changed by a similar amount with split and full-body routines. The authors concluded people can choose a routine based on personal preference when volume is equated (Ramos-Campo et al., 2024).

The studies measured bench press and lower-body strength, plus muscle size in the arms and thighs. On every one of those outcomes, the differences between routines were small and not statistically significant. That covers what most lifters care about.

Older single studies sometimes favoured full body. In one 8-week study of 20 trained men, a 3-day full-body routine grew the forearm flexors more than a once-a-week body part split (Schoenfeld et al., 2015). But that compared hitting a muscle three times a week with once a week. PPL and upper/lower both hit each muscle about twice a week, so that gap mostly does not apply.

How do the three splits compare side by side?

  • Full body: 2-4 days a week. Each muscle trained 2-4 times. Sessions cover everything, so you do fewer sets per muscle each session.
  • Upper/lower: 4 days a week. Each muscle trained twice. Moderate session length with room for more sets per muscle than full body.
  • Push/pull/legs: 3 or 6 days a week. Run 6 days and each muscle gets trained twice. Run 3 days and it drops to once a week.
  • Total weekly sets per muscle can be the same in all three. That is the number that drives growth.

Which split is best if I can only train 3 days a week?

Full body. Three full-body sessions hit each muscle three times. A 3-day PPL hits each muscle once, which packs all of a muscle's weekly sets into one session. By the end of that session, quality drops and the extra sets do less.

Keep each session to about 5-6 exercises. The aim is a few hard sets per muscle each session, not a full bodybuilding workout three times over.

A simple 3-day plan uses a squat or leg press, a hinge, a press, a pull and one or two small exercises each session, with different variations on each day.

When is upper/lower the better choice?

Upper/lower suits people who can reliably train 4 days, like Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday. Each muscle gets two sessions a week. Sessions stay a manageable length. It also forgives a missed day better than PPL, because you can shift to a full-body session that week without losing much.

Is push/pull/legs worth it for busy people?

Only if you will actually train 5-6 days. PPL shines for people who like being in the gym most days and want shorter, focused sessions. The risk is life. Miss two sessions and a muscle group may go 10 or more days untrained. For parents, shift workers and people who travel for work, that happens a lot.

If you like PPL but cannot commit to 6 days, run it on a rolling basis: push, pull, legs, rest, repeat. Each muscle then gets trained every 4 days, which works out to a little under twice a week.

A 6-week study in trained men found that 3 and 6 sessions a week produced similar strength and muscle gains when volume matched (Saric et al., 2019). Training more days is not magic. It just spreads the work out.

What does a week look like on each split?

  • Full body, 3 days: Monday squat, bench press, row, curls. Wednesday Romanian deadlift, overhead press, pulldown, lateral raises. Friday leg press, incline press, cable row, triceps.
  • Upper/lower, 4 days: Monday upper, Tuesday lower, Thursday upper, Friday lower. Use heavier sets early in the week and higher reps later.
  • Push/pull/legs, 6 days: push on Monday and Thursday, pull on Tuesday and Friday, legs on Wednesday and Saturday.

Notice where the fatigue sits. A PPL legs day piles all lower-body work into one session, which can leave you flat for a day or two. Full body spreads it out, so no single session wrecks you. Upper/lower sits in the middle.

For busy parents and people over 40, full body or upper/lower is usually the better fit. Both need fewer days, both cope with a missed session, and both hit each muscle at least twice a week. Recovery also tends to be the limiter for people juggling work, kids and broken sleep. Fewer, well-planned sessions are easier to recover from than six days of training squeezed into an already full week.

How do I pick the right split for me?

  • Count the days you can train in a bad week, not a good one.
  • 2-3 days: full body.
  • 4 days: upper/lower.
  • 5-6 days and a flexible schedule: PPL or a PPL plus upper/lower hybrid.
  • Aim for about 10 or more hard sets per muscle per week in whichever split you choose. That was the highest volume band in a 2017 meta-analysis on training volume, and it linked more weekly sets to more growth.

Then stay with it for at least 8-12 weeks. Changing splits every month makes progress impossible to measure. If you want a split built around your days, the structured programs in the MBM app are designed by days per week. It launches soon and early access is open.

Common questions

Is PPL good for beginners?

It can work, but full body is usually better for beginners. More frequent practice of each lift helps technique, and three sessions a week is easier to keep.

Can I combine upper/lower and PPL?

Yes. A 5-day week of upper, lower, push, pull, legs is a common hybrid. It hits each muscle about twice and suits people who train most weekdays.

Is a bro split bad?

A once-a-week body part split can still build muscle, but it packs all weekly sets for a muscle into one session. Training a muscle twice a week with the same sets is usually a better use of the work.

How long should each session be?

Long enough to finish your planned hard sets with proper rest, and no longer. If sessions run past what your week allows, trim junk sets or move some work to another day.

Sources

  1. Ramos-Campo et al. (2024), J Strength Cond Res - Split vs full-body resistance training meta-analysis
  2. Schoenfeld et al. (2015), J Strength Cond Res - Training frequency in well-trained men
  3. Saric et al. (2019), J Strength Cond Res - Training 3 vs 6 times per week
  4. Schoenfeld et al. (2017), J Sports Sci - Dose-response of weekly training volume
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog