Does No Soreness Mean No Muscle Growth?
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
No. You can build muscle without getting sore. In one 8-week study, a group that avoided soreness gained the same muscle size and strength as a group that got very sore, with strength up 25% versus 26%. Soreness mainly reflects how new a workout is. Track progressive overload, effort and weekly sets instead.
Not being sore doesn't mean your training stopped working. Soreness mostly tells you a session was new, unusual or heavy on lowering the weight. It fades as your body adapts, while muscle growth can keep going for years. If you train hard, add weight or reps over time and eat enough protein, you can grow without ever feeling wrecked the next day.
Why do you stop getting sore after a few weeks?
Your muscles adapt to protect themselves. After one bout of an unfamiliar exercise, repeating it causes much less damage and soreness. This is called the repeated bout effect. Researchers propose it involves adaptations in the nervous system, the muscle's mechanical properties, the connective tissue around the fibres and biochemical signalling, all working together (Hyldahl et al., 2017).
So when the soreness disappears in week three of a program, it's a sign of adaptation, not of the program failing. It's the same reason a returning lifter gets very sore in their first session back but barely notices it a month later.
Can you build muscle without soreness?
Yes, and there's direct evidence. In an 8-week eccentric cycling study, one group was eased in with a 3-week ramp-up so they avoided noticeable muscle damage. The other group started with a damaging session. The damaged group had creatine kinase levels, a blood marker of muscle damage, more than five times higher, and reported more soreness. Yet muscle size and strength gains were the same in both groups. Strength rose 25% in the ramp-up group and 26% in the damaged group (Flann et al., 2011).
The authors concluded that muscle growth can begin without any noticeable damage. Soreness was extra baggage, not a requirement.
Does muscle damage help muscle growth at all?
Not in the way people assume. A 2016 study took muscle biopsies from 10 young men across 10 weeks of resistance training. Muscle damage and protein synthesis were both highest after the first week of sessions, but neither was linked to muscle growth. Later, at weeks 3 and 10, when damage had dropped to minimal levels, the protein synthesis after each session did correlate with growth (Damas et al., 2016).
The authors concluded that growth comes from repeated rises in muscle protein synthesis, mainly after damage has been reduced. Early on, a lot of your body's repair work goes into fixing damage rather than adding new muscle. That suggests the sore, high-damage phase isn't the part of training that builds muscle.
What does soreness actually tell you?
A review of DOMS notes it is most common when people return after time off or start a new type of activity, and that eccentric work causes more micro-injury than other muscle actions (Cheung et al., 2003). So soreness mostly tells you:
- The exercise was new to you.
- You did a lot of slow lowering or loaded stretching, like Romanian deadlifts or deep lunges.
- You came back after a break.
- You jumped your volume up quickly.
None of those are the same as an effective session. Some of the best muscle-building exercises, such as machine presses and cable work, rarely cause much soreness once you're used to them.
Can too much soreness actually slow your progress?
It can. Heavy soreness has a cost that the no pain, no gain idea ignores. The Cheung review notes that DOMS can reduce joint range of motion and peak force, and change how muscles fire, for several days after a session (Cheung et al., 2003). If you're very sore, your next session for that muscle is likely to be weaker, shorter or done with worse technique.
Muscle growth depends on stacking good sessions week after week. A workout that leaves you hobbling for four days can cost you a session or two of quality work, which outweighs any benefit from the extra effort. The better target is a session hard enough to challenge you, but recoverable enough that you can train that muscle again within a few days. Mild soreness now and then is fine. Chasing it every week is a poor trade.
What should you track instead of soreness?
These markers show if you're growing:
- Progressive overload: more weight or more reps on the same exercises over weeks.
- Effort: most working sets ending within about 1-3 reps of failure.
- Weekly sets: a consistent number of hard sets per muscle group each week.
- Body measurements: arm, chest and thigh circumference every 4 weeks.
- Photos in the same light and pose every 4 weeks.
- Body weight trend, if you're trying to gain.
If your numbers on key lifts are going up over a month or two, you're very likely building muscle, sore or not. For a full guide, read progressive overload and how to do it. Following a structured program also helps, because it sets the sets and progression for you. The MBM app, launching soon, includes structured programs and Move IQ, which uses your phone camera to count reps and flag reps that miss range, so you know your sets are real.
What if you never get sore and never progress?
Then the issue is probably effort or progression, not soreness. Common causes:
- Sets that stop far short of failure, with 5 or more reps left.
- Lifting the same weights for the same reps for months.
- Too few hard sets per muscle per week.
- Not eating enough protein or total food to support growth.
- Short sleep most nights.
Fix those, and growth usually follows. Chasing soreness with random new exercises every week tends to do the opposite. It keeps you in the early high-damage phase where, as the Damas study showed, protein synthesis isn't yet linked to growth.
Common questions
Is it bad to be sore after every workout?
It isn't harmful, but it often means you're changing exercises too often or doing more volume than you recover from. Consistent programs usually produce less soreness and steadier progress.
Should I change my program to get sore again?
No. Change your program when progress stalls for several weeks, not when soreness fades. Swapping exercises constantly makes it harder to track overload and keeps you in the adaptation phase.
Why do I still get sore in some muscles but not others?
Muscles trained through long ranges with slow lowering, like hamstrings and glutes, tend to stay sore more. Muscles you train often, or with exercises that have less stretch under load, adapt and stop getting sore sooner.
Does no soreness mean I didn't train hard enough?
Not on its own. Judge effort by how close your sets came to failure and whether your weights or reps are improving. A hard session on a familiar program can leave you with little or no soreness.
Sources
- Flann et al. (2011), Journal of Experimental Biology - Muscle damage and muscle remodeling: no pain, no gain?
- Damas et al. (2016), Journal of Physiology - Myofibrillar protein synthesis, muscle damage and hypertrophy
- Hyldahl et al. (2017), Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews - Mechanisms of the repeated bout effect
- Cheung et al. (2003), Sports Medicine - Delayed onset muscle soreness: treatment strategies and performance factors
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.