How to Deload: Cut the Weight or Cut the Volume?
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
Cut volume first. Drop weekly sets by roughly half, keep the weight moderately heavy, and stop every set several reps short of failure. Research suggests load is the key to keeping strength while volume can drop a lot. Lower the weight as well if your joints ache or you feel run down from life stress.
You have three levers in a deload: volume (sets and reps), load (the weight on the bar) and effort (how close to failure you go). For most people the best default is to cut volume hard, cut effort hard, and reduce load only a little. That clears fatigue while keeping you used to heavy weights. If your joints are what feel beaten up, lower the load more.
What do experienced lifters change during a deload?
A 2024 survey of 246 competitive strength and physique athletes by Rogerson and colleagues asked exactly this. Most athletes pulled more than one lever:
- Cut weekly sets: 78.9% of athletes
- Cut reps per set: 52.8%
- Lowered load on multi-joint lifts: 83.7%
- Lowered load on single-joint lifts: 60.2%
- Left more reps in reserve on multi-joint lifts: 84.9%
- Kept the same sessions per week: 63.0%
- Kept the same range of motion: about 90%
So the typical deload cuts volume and effort, drops the load somewhat, and keeps the schedule and exercises the same. A 2023 Delphi consensus of expert coaches backed this up. All of them agreed volume should drop through fewer sets and reps, and that proximity to failure should drop. On load they were more flexible. 95.2% agreed intensity can stay the same as normal training while volume is reduced, and 81.0% agreed intensity could remain high.
Why is cutting volume usually the better first move?
Because strength and muscle hold up well on very little volume, as long as the weight stays reasonably heavy. A 2021 review by Spiering and colleagues looked at the minimum dose needed to maintain fitness. In younger people, strength and muscle size were maintained for up to 32 weeks with as little as one strength session a week and one set per exercise, provided relative load was maintained. The authors concluded that intensity seems to be the key variable for maintaining performance.
A 2011 trial by Bickel and colleagues found something similar. After 16 weeks of training, young adults kept their muscle gains over 32 weeks on one-third, and even one-ninth, of their original training dose. Older adults needed more to hold their muscle, though they kept their strength well.
If that much reduction works for months, a single week at half volume won't cost you anything meaningful. Keeping the weight fairly heavy also means your first session back doesn't feel foreign.
When should you cut the weight instead?
Lower the load more when the fatigue is in your joints and connective tissue rather than your muscles, or when you're generally run down. Good reasons to go lighter:
- Elbows, knees, shoulders or lower back ache during warm-ups
- You've been grinding heavy singles, doubles or triples for weeks
- Bar speed is slow even on warm-up weights
- Sleep, stress or illness have knocked you around
- You're in a long calorie deficit
In these cases, keep the same exercises but use a weight you could lift for many more reps than you're doing. Moving well with lighter loads still keeps the pattern practised.
Is a full week off better than a light week?
Probably not for most lifters. In a 2024 trial by Coleman and colleagues, trained lifters who stopped resistance training completely for one week mid-program grew just as much muscle as those who kept training. Strength gains favoured the continuous group though, and the deload group reported feeling lethargic or out of practice afterwards.
The authors suggested a reduced-volume or reduced-intensity week might clear fatigue without that cost, while noting this hasn't been tested yet. For now, a light week is the safer default. Save complete rest for illness, injury, or when you genuinely can't face the gym.
What are three simple deload templates?
Pick one based on how you feel. All three keep your normal training days and main exercises.
- Volume deload (default): halve your sets, keep about 90% of your usual working weight, stop every set 3-4 reps short of failure
- Load deload (for sore joints): keep about half your usual sets, drop the weight noticeably, keep reps smooth and fast, finish well short of failure
- Minimum deload (busy week): 2-3 short sessions of your main lifts only, 1-2 sets each at moderate weight
Skip most accessories. The Delphi coaches agreed, at 85.7%, that assistance exercises can be removed during a deload, and at 100% that main exercises should stay in with lower volume or intensity.
How do you set the right weight on the day?
Use how the warm-ups feel. If the bar moves fast and nothing hurts, a volume deload at near-normal weight is fine. If warm-ups feel heavy or achy, switch to the load deload. The MBM app, launching soon, turns a daily readiness check-in into a load suggestion, such as starting at 85% of your usual weight, which takes some of the guesswork out of this choice.
Whatever you pick, the test is simple. You should leave each deload session feeling better than when you walked in. If you don't, cut more.
What should you do the week after a deload?
Come back with a plan rather than jumping straight to your heaviest sets. In the Rogerson survey, 67.9% of athletes started a new training block after their deload. The Delphi coaches agreed, at 95.2%, that a deload can be used to introduce exercises for the next block, so the new movements are already familiar when the hard work starts.
A simple re-entry looks like this. In week one, return to your normal sets but leave 2-3 reps in reserve. In week two, start pushing your top sets again. If you cut load heavily during the deload, expect the first heavy session to feel slightly strange. That's normal, and it passes as you get back into the rhythm.
Common questions
How many reps in reserve should I leave in a deload?
There's no agreed number. The Delphi coaches agreed effort should drop but didn't settle on a target. Stopping 3-4 or more reps short of failure on every set is a practical starting point.
Should I change exercises during a deload?
Mostly no. The Delphi coaches agreed at 100% that familiar exercises should stay in to avoid soreness from a new stimulus. Some coaches introduce next block's exercises at light loads during the deload.
Can I deload one muscle group only?
Yes. If only your legs or shoulders feel beaten up, reduce volume and load for that area and train the rest normally. A full-body deload makes more sense when fatigue is general.
Do I deload cardio too?
If you do hard conditioning, reduce it in the same way. Easy walking or relaxed cycling is fine to keep, because it adds little fatigue.
Sources
- Rogerson et al. (2024), Sports Medicine Open - Deloading practices in strength and physique sports: a cross-sectional survey
- Bell et al. (2023), Sports Medicine Open - Integrating deloading into strength and physique sports training programmes: a Delphi consensus
- Spiering et al. (2021), Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research - Maintaining physical performance: the minimal dose of exercise needed
- Bickel, Cross and Bamman (2011), Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise - Exercise dosing to retain resistance training adaptations
- Coleman et al. (2024), PeerJ - The effects of a one-week deload period during supervised resistance training on muscular adaptations
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.