How to Adjust Your Training Load on a Bad Day
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
Keep the session but train to the planned effort, not the planned weight. If your first working set feels 1-2 points harder on the RPE scale than it should, drop the load by about 5-10% and keep the reps. Cut one set from the main lifts if you are still dragging. Keep isolation work mostly as written.
Everyone has days when the bar feels heavy before you even lift it. Short sleep, a stressful week or a long day at work all show up in the gym. The answer is rarely to skip the session or to force the numbers anyway. Adjust the load so the effort matches the plan, get good quality work done, and move on. One lighter day does not undo weeks of training.
How much does a bad night or stressful day affect strength?
Enough to notice, but less than it feels. A meta-analysis of 69 studies found that sleep loss reduced exercise performance by about 7.6% on average. Performance fell by roughly 0.4% for every hour awake before exercise, and tasks done in the morning were largely unaffected compared with those done later in the day (Craven et al., 2022).
The type of lift matters too. A systematic review of 17 studies found that several nights of restricted sleep could reduce force output on multi-joint lifts such as squats and presses, but not on single-joint movements (Knowles et al., 2018). So the big compound lifts are where you will feel a bad day most.
How do you know if today is actually a bad day?
Use your warm-ups and first working set as a test. Compare how they feel with how they normally feel at that weight. Signs that you should adjust:
- Your usual warm-up weights feel noticeably heavier or slower.
- Your first working set lands 1-2 points higher on the RPE scale than planned, for example an RPE 9 when the plan said RPE 7-8.
- Your technique slips at loads that are normally easy.
- You slept much less than usual, or have been awake far longer than normal before training.
A rough mood before training is not enough on its own. Plenty of sessions that start badly turn out fine once you are warm. Judge by the bar, not by how you felt in the car park.
How much should you drop the weight?
Train to the effort the program calls for. The repetitions in reserve (RIR) based RPE scale was designed for this: it adjusts loads to match an athlete's capability on a set-to-set basis (Helms et al., 2016). If the plan says 3 sets of 5 at RPE 8, pick the weight that gives you RPE 8 today, even if it is lighter than last week.
In practice, that usually means dropping the load by about 5-10% on the main lifts. That range lines up with the average 7.6% dip in performance after sleep loss. Simple rules that work:
- First working set 1 RPE point too high: take 5% off and keep the planned sets and reps.
- First working set 2 or more points too high: take about 10% off and drop one set.
- Still grinding after the drop: finish the main lift at that weight, skip the hardest accessory, and leave.
- Feel good after warming up: go back to the planned load.
Which exercises should you change first on a bad day?
Start with the big barbell lifts. Restricted sleep tends to reduce force on multi-joint movements but not single-joint ones (Knowles et al., 2018). They are also the lifts where a technical slip costs most. A sensible order of changes:
- Heavy squats, deadlifts and presses: adjust load by effort first, as above.
- Swap a barbell lift for a machine or dumbbell version if your technique feels off, keeping similar sets and reps.
- Keep isolation work such as curls, raises and leg extensions close to the plan.
- Leave out new personal bests and max attempts until you feel normal again.
This keeps most of the useful training in the session while removing the parts that carry the most risk on a tired day.
Does training lighter on bad days slow your progress?
The evidence suggests not. In an 8-week study of trained men, one group lifted fixed percentages of their 1RM while the other chose loads to hit a target RPE. Both made similar gains in strength and muscle, with a small non-significant edge to the RPE group in squat strength (Helms et al., 2018). In college footballers, a flexible system that adjusted loads to daily performance improved bench press and squat strength more than fixed weekly increases over 6 weeks (Mann et al., 2010).
Doing fewer reps on a hard day also costs little. In one squat study, stopping sets once bar speed fell by 20% produced similar strength gains to stopping at 40%, even though the 20% group did 40% fewer reps (Pareja-Blanco et al., 2017). The last grinding reps were not where most of the strength came from.
Should you just skip the session instead?
Usually not. A lighter session keeps your routine and your technique practice going, and you often feel better afterwards. Skip or swap to a walk if you are unwell, injured or in pain, or if you are so short on sleep that driving or lifting heavy would be unsafe. If you are sick, in pain that lasts, or regularly sleeping badly, see your GP or a relevant health professional.
If bad days start to outnumber good ones, look at the bigger picture: sleep, total training volume, food and life stress. A planned lighter week may help more than lots of small cuts.
How can you plan for bad days in advance?
Build flexibility into your program so you are not deciding everything mid-session. Use RPE or RIR targets on the main lifts, write in an optional last set, and keep a short list of swaps for days when one lift feels off.
A short check-in before training helps too. The MBM app, launching soon, includes a daily readiness check-in where you score sleep, soreness, stress, energy and mood from 1-10. It turns those scores into a readiness score and a load suggestion, such as starting at 85% of your planned load. Early access is at /app.
Common questions
Is it better to cut weight or cut sets on a bad day?
Start by cutting weight so you keep the planned reps with good form. If you are still struggling after one or two sets, cut a set as well. Keep the movement quality high either way.
Should I train in the morning if I slept badly?
If your schedule allows, earlier can help. Research on sleep loss found morning performance was largely unaffected, while the effects built up with more hours awake. Caffeine and training with others may also help.
What if every day feels like a bad day?
That points to a bigger problem than one session. Review sleep, stress, food and how much training you are doing. A lighter week often helps, and see your GP if poor sleep or fatigue continues.
Do isolation exercises need adjusting too?
Less often. Sleep restriction tends to hit multi-joint lifts harder than single-joint ones. Keep curls, raises and machine work close to the plan unless they feel clearly off.
Sources
- Craven et al. (2022), Sports Medicine - Effects of acute sleep loss on physical performance
- Knowles et al. (2018), Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport - Inadequate sleep and muscle strength
- Helms et al. (2016), Strength and Conditioning Journal - Application of the RIR-based RPE scale
- Helms et al. (2018), Frontiers in Physiology - RPE vs percentage 1RM loading in periodized programs
- Mann et al. (2010), Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research - Autoregulatory progressive resistance exercise vs linear periodization
- Pareja-Blanco et al. (2017), Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports - Velocity loss during resistance training
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.