Am I Overtraining? Symptoms to Watch For
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
Probably not. True overtraining syndrome is rare, especially in people who lift weights. Its main sign is performance that keeps dropping for weeks or months despite rest, often with fatigue, poor sleep, low mood and loss of motivation. Most gym-goers who feel run down are short-term overreached, which a week or two of easier training fixes.
If you're asking this question, you're most likely tired, not overtrained. Overtraining syndrome is a real medical condition, but it's uncommon and usually seen in athletes doing very large training loads. What most people feel is short-term overreaching: a few weeks of training harder than they're recovering from. The difference matters, because one clears with a deload and the other can take months.
What are the symptoms of overtraining syndrome?
A widely cited review by Kreher and Schwartz in Sports Health lists the symptoms reported with overtraining syndrome:
- Fatigue and waking up unrefreshed
- Insomnia and restlessness
- Loss of appetite and weight loss
- Depression, anxiety and irritability
- Loss of motivation and poor concentration
- Heavy, sore or stiff muscles
- Changes in resting heart rate, either higher or lower than usual
- Raised blood pressure
None of these symptoms is unique to overtraining. Every one can come from poor sleep, stress, illness or diet. That's why the defining feature is a long-lasting drop in performance that rest doesn't fix.
How is overtraining different from overreaching?
Researchers describe a spectrum. The Kreher review, drawing on the European College of Sport Science definitions, lays it out like this:
- Functional overreaching: a short-term dip in performance after hard training that recovers within days to weeks, often followed by improvement
- Non-functional overreaching: a longer dip lasting weeks to months, with psychological or hormonal symptoms, that does fully recover with rest
- Overtraining syndrome: a performance drop lasting more than 2 months, with more severe symptoms, that can't be explained by another illness
The review notes some clinicians use a practical cut-off. If less than 14-21 days of rest gets performance back, it's non-functional overreaching. If it takes longer, overtraining syndrome becomes a possibility. The ECSS and ACSM joint consensus notes it's possible to recover from short-term overreaching within about 2 weeks, while overtrained athletes may take months or even years.
Why do other stresses make it feel like overtraining?
The ECSS and ACSM consensus defines overreaching and overtraining as an accumulation of training and non-training stress. It lists inadequate food intake, illness, psychosocial stress from work and family, and sleep problems as common confounding factors. In other words, the gym is only part of the picture.
This is why a program that felt easy in January can flatten you in June. The sets didn't change. Your sleep, workload or calorie intake did. A new baby, a big project at work or a long diet can push you into overreaching on training you normally handle without trouble. When you feel run down, look at your whole week as well as your training log before you decide what to change.
How common is overtraining in people who lift?
Rare. A 2020 scoping review by Bell and colleagues included 47 studies on overreaching and overtraining in strength sports and resistance training. The authors found minimal evidence that true overtraining syndrome has occurred in those groups. The Kreher review describes overtraining syndrome in general as extremely rare, though exact numbers are lacking.
Non-functional overreaching is more common, mostly in endurance athletes. The Kreher review cites a lifetime rate of about 60% in elite runners, compared with 33% in non-elite female runners. For a busy adult lifting three to five times a week, outright overtraining syndrome is very unlikely.
How is overtraining diagnosed?
By ruling other things out. The ECSS and ACSM consensus states there's no single test. Diagnosis involves excluding medical causes first, such as thyroid, adrenal or blood sugar problems, infections, iron deficiency and eating in a large energy deficit. Hormone, blood and psychological tests have all been studied, but none meets the criteria to be generally accepted as a diagnostic marker.
For lifters specifically, a 2020 review by Grandou and colleagues found no marker other than a sustained performance decrease has been established as a reliable sign of overtraining from resistance exercise. The same review noted overtraining may be linked to frequent, high-intensity, monotonous training.
If you've had fatigue, low mood, poor sleep or falling performance for several weeks, see a GP. Don't self-diagnose overtraining. Many treatable conditions look the same.
What should you do if you think you're overtrained?
Start with an honest easy week. If performance and mood bounce back within one to two weeks of lighter training, you were overreached, not overtrained. That's good news. Look at what pushed you there and adjust: training volume, sleep, food and stress.
If symptoms persist past a couple of weeks of genuine rest, see your GP. The ECSS and ACSM consensus says rest and very light training seem to be the only therapeutic agents for true overtraining, and that prevention is the priority. The Kreher review suggests returning gradually, building volume before intensity, starting with 5-10 minutes of daily exercise and working up until an hour is tolerated. Do that with professional guidance.
How do you avoid getting there?
The ECSS and ACSM consensus names an imbalance between training load and recovery as one of the most certain triggers. Its main recommendations are simple:
- Keep a daily training log, including how you feel
- Take at least one passive rest day each week
- Get enough sleep, as persistent sleep loss affects training quality and wellbeing
- Avoid long stretches of monotonous, very hard training
- Catch overreaching early, when a short deload is enough
A short daily check-in makes the log easy. The MBM app, launching soon, scores sleep, soreness, stress, energy and mood each morning and turns them into a readiness score, so a slide over several weeks is obvious long before it becomes a problem.
Common questions
Can you overtrain by going to the gym every day?
Daily training on its own rarely causes overtraining syndrome. Problems usually come from high intensity with no variation, little rest and outside stress combined. The ECSS and ACSM consensus recommends at least one passive rest day each week.
Does overtraining raise or lower your resting heart rate?
It can do either. The Kreher review lists both a faster and a slower heart rate among reported symptoms. A change from your normal resting heart rate is worth noting but isn't diagnostic by itself.
How long does it take to recover from overtraining?
Short-term overreaching often clears within about 2 weeks. True overtraining syndrome involves performance drops of over 2 months and can take months to resolve. A doctor should guide recovery.
Sources
- Kreher and Schwartz (2012), Sports Health - Overtraining syndrome: a practical guide
- Meeusen et al. (2013), ECSS and ACSM joint consensus statement - Prevention, diagnosis and treatment of the overtraining syndrome
- Bell et al. (2020), Journal of Sports Sciences - Overreaching and overtraining in strength sports and resistance training: a scoping review
- Grandou et al. (2020), Sports Medicine - Overtraining in resistance exercise: an exploratory systematic review
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.