5x5 vs 3x8: Which Is Better for Strength and Size?
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
5x5 is better for building maximal strength because it uses heavier loads. 3x8 builds about the same muscle when sets are hard, takes less time and is easier on joints. If strength is your main goal, lean on 5x5 for the big lifts. If size is the goal, 3x8 works well. Many programs use both.
It depends on what you want. Both schemes add up to almost the same number of reps, 25 versus 24. The difference is the load. Sets of five let you use heavier weights, which builds more maximal strength. Sets of eight use moderate weights, which build muscle just as well in less time. For most people, the best answer is to use each where it fits.
What is the difference between 5x5 and 3x8?
5x5 means five sets of five reps. 3x8 means three sets of eight. The total reps are close, but the weight on the bar is not.
- 5x5 uses a weight you could lift a few more times than five, so most sets end with reps in reserve. Rest is usually 3-5 minutes.
- 3x8 uses a lighter weight you could lift a few more times than eight. Rest is usually 1-2 minutes, a little longer on big lifts.
- 5x5 sessions take longer because you do more sets with longer rests.
- Both work best when the weight goes up steadily over weeks.
The ACSM position stand on progression reflects this split. It recommends emphasising heavy loads in the 1-6 rep range with 3-5 minutes of rest for strength, and the 6-12 rep range with 1-2 minutes of rest for hypertrophy.
Which builds more strength?
Heavier sets, so 5x5 has the edge. A 2017 meta-analysis by Schoenfeld and colleagues of 21 studies found 1-rep max gains were greater with heavy loads than with light loads. A 2021 network meta-analysis by Lopez and colleagues reached the same conclusion across 28 studies. Strength gains were superior with high and moderate loads compared with low loads, with a non-significant edge for high over moderate.
Direct comparisons in trained lifters agree. A 2015 study by Mangine and colleagues compared 4 sets of 3-5 reps at about 90% of max with 4 sets of 10-12 at about 70%. After 8 weeks, bench press 1-rep max rose 14.8% in the heavy group and 6.9% in the moderate group.
Strength is specific. Practising heavy sets makes you better at heavy lifting, both in muscle and in skill. If you compete in powerlifting or simply want a bigger 1-rep max, you need regular exposure to heavy weights. Sets of eight alone will build a base, but they will not fully prepare you to handle a near-maximal bar.
Which builds more muscle?
They are about even. The Schoenfeld meta-analysis found similar muscle growth across a wide range of loads. Lopez and colleagues also found no difference in hypertrophy between low, moderate and high loads when sets were taken to failure.
A 2014 study by Schoenfeld and colleagues tested a heavy and a moderate scheme head to head. Trained men did either 7 sets of 3 reps or 3 sets of 10, with total volume load matched. After 8 weeks, biceps growth was similar. The heavy group gained more bench press strength.
So for muscle, 3x8 gets you the same result with fewer sets and shorter rests. That is a real advantage for busy people.
Does volume change the answer?
Yes. For muscle, total hard sets per week matter more than whether those sets are fives or eights. A 2017 meta-analysis by Schoenfeld and colleagues found 10 or more weekly sets per muscle produced 9.8% growth versus 5.4% for fewer than 5 sets.
This is where 5x5 programs can come up short for size. Many beginner 5x5 programs run three full-body sessions built mostly around compound lifts, so smaller muscles like side delts, biceps and hamstrings may not get much direct work. Adding a few sets of 8-12 for those muscles fixes it.
Which fits a busy schedule better?
3x8, by a clear margin. Do the maths on one exercise. Five sets with 3-5 minutes of rest between them takes roughly 15-25 minutes once you count the sets themselves. Three sets with about 2 minutes of rest takes under 10. Across four or five exercises, that gap adds up to most of an hour.
If you only have 45 minutes, a session built entirely on 5x5 forces you to cut exercises. A session built on 3x8 lets you train more muscles in the same time, which helps if muscle growth is your goal. A good middle ground is to use 5x5 for one main lift and 3x8 for the rest of the session. You keep heavy practice where it matters most and still finish on time.
Which is better for beginners?
Either works, because beginners improve on almost anything done consistently. 5x5 is popular because it is simple and teaches heavy compound lifts early. 3x8 is a good choice if you are learning technique, since more reps per set give more practice at a manageable weight, and if you are short on time.
If you are over 40, returning after a long break, or nursing sore joints, start with 3x8. Move to heavier sets once your technique is solid and your joints have adapted.
How do you combine 5x5 and 3x8?
Most well-designed programs already do. Use heavier sets for your main lifts and moderate sets for everything else.
- Main lift of the day (squat, bench, deadlift or press): 5x5 or 4x4-6.
- Second compound lift: 3x8.
- Accessories and isolation work: 3x8-12.
- Alternatively, run a heavy day with 5x5 and a volume day with 3x8 for the same lift each week.
That mix gets you the strength benefit of heavy sets and the efficient growth of moderate ones. If you would rather follow a plan that already balances the two, the MBM app is launching soon with structured programs for strength, size or both.
Common questions
Is 5x5 good for building muscle?
Yes, as long as you also get enough weekly volume. Heavier sets build muscle well when taken close to failure, but 5x5 programs often need extra isolation work for smaller muscles.
Is 3x8 enough to get stronger?
Yes, especially for beginners. Intermediate and advanced lifters chasing a bigger 1-rep max will usually need some heavier sets of 1-6 reps as well.
How much weight should I add each week on 5x5?
Beginners often add 2.5 kg to upper body lifts and 2.5-5 kg to lower body lifts each session or week. When you start missing reps, switch to slower weekly or monthly progression.
Sources
- American College of Sports Medicine (2009), Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise - Progression models in resistance training
- Schoenfeld et al. (2017), Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research - Low- vs high-load training
- Lopez et al. (2021), Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise - Training load, hypertrophy and strength network meta-analysis
- Mangine et al. (2015), Physiological Reports - Training volume and intensity in resistance-trained men
- Schoenfeld et al. (2014), Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research - Volume-equated loading strategies in trained men
- Schoenfeld et al. (2017), Journal of Sports Sciences - Weekly training volume and muscle mass
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.