← Back to blog
Beginners· 5 min read

What Weight Should I Start With at the Gym?

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

Start with a weight you can lift for 8-12 clean reps while still having 2-3 reps left in the tank. Find it by doing light ramp-up sets and adding weight until the last reps slow down but form holds. Then keep that weight until you beat your target reps, and add 2-10% load.

There's no magic starting number. The right weight is one you can lift for 8-12 controlled reps with a couple of reps to spare. For one person that's an empty 20 kg bar on the squat. For another it's 8 kg dumbbells. You find it by testing, not by copying someone else.

How do you know if a weight is right for you?

The American College of Sports Medicine recommends that novices use loads corresponding to an 8-12 repetition maximum. That means a weight you could lift for about 8-12 reps before you couldn't do another with good form.

As a beginner, you don't want to hit that limit on every set. Use reps in reserve (RIR), which is how many more good reps you could have done. Zourdos and colleagues validated an RIR-based effort scale in 2016, where RPE 10 means no reps left and RPE 8 means two left. Aim to finish sets with 2-3 reps left while you learn.

  • Too light: you finish 10 reps and could clearly do 5 or more extra.
  • About right: reps 8-10 slow down a little, form stays the same, and you could do 2-3 more.
  • Too heavy: your form changes, you lose range, or you can't reach 8 reps.

How do you find your starting weight on day one?

Use ramp-up sets. They double as your warm-up and stop you guessing.

  • Set 1: a very light weight, or the empty bar, for 10 reps. Focus on the movement.
  • Set 2: add a small amount and do 8-10 reps.
  • Set 3: add again. If the reps still feel easy, keep going.
  • Stop climbing when the last 2-3 reps start to slow. That's your working weight for the day.

Write it down. Next session, start your working sets at that weight. Your first few sessions will be partly about learning, so expect the weight to move up quickly at first.

Don't worry if your ramp-up takes four or five sets on the first day. It's a one-off. From the second session, you'll know your working weight and only need one or two light sets as a warm-up.

Does lifting light weights still build muscle?

Yes. A 2017 meta-analysis of 21 studies by Schoenfeld and colleagues found muscle growth was similar between low loads (60% of one-rep max or less) and high loads (above 60%) when sets were taken to failure. Heavier loads were better for building maximal strength.

A 2021 review by the same group argued that muscle can be built across a wide spectrum of loads. For a beginner, that's reassuring. Starting a little light costs you nothing, as long as you push the sets reasonably hard and increase the load over time.

You also don't need to grind to failure. A 2022 meta-analysis of 15 studies found no significant difference in muscle or strength gains between training to failure and stopping short.

The practical rule: lighter is fine, easy is not. Whatever weight you pick, the last few reps of each set should feel genuinely hard.

When should you increase the weight?

Use double progression. Pick a rep range, such as 8-12. Stay at the same weight until you can hit 12 reps on every set with good form. Then increase the load and work back up from 8 reps.

The ACSM recommends increasing load by 2-10% once you can do one or two reps more than your target. On a 40 kg leg press, that's about 1-4 kg. Use the smaller end for upper-body and isolation exercises, and the larger end for big leg exercises.

Not every session will bring a jump. Some weeks you'll add a rep, some weeks a set feels easier at the same weight, and some weeks nothing changes. That's normal. Look at your log across four weeks, not session to session, and you'll see the trend.

What if the gym's weight jumps are too big?

Dumbbell racks commonly go up in fixed steps of a couple of kilograms, which can be a big jump on small exercises like lateral raises. Your options:

  • Add reps before weight. Push to 15 reps, then move up and drop back to 8-10.
  • Add a set at the current weight before going heavier.
  • Use a machine or cable stack with smaller steps for that exercise.
  • Slow the lowering phase to 3 seconds to make the same weight harder.

Does the starting point differ between exercises?

Yes. You are much stronger on some movements than others, so find a starting weight for each exercise separately. A few general patterns help you set expectations:

  • Leg exercises such as the leg press and squat usually take the most weight, because they use the biggest muscles.
  • Pulling exercises like rows and pulldowns usually come next.
  • Pressing overhead is usually much lighter than pressing on a bench.
  • Isolation exercises such as lateral raises and curls need light weights. Start very light on these.

Machines and free weights aren't comparable either. A 40 kg machine press and 40 kg on a barbell won't feel the same, because each machine is built differently. Treat each piece of equipment as its own starting point, and write down which machine you used.

What starting weight mistakes should you avoid?

Copying the person next to you. Going heavy on day one and getting so sore you miss the next week. Staying at the same light weight for months because it feels comfortable. Cutting range so the weight looks heavier.

Structured programs in the MBM app will log your weights and tell you when to add load, and the daily readiness check-in can suggest a lighter day, such as starting at 85% load, when sleep or soreness is off. It is launching soon, with early access at /app.

Common questions

What weight should a beginner bench press?

Many beginners start with the empty bar, which is usually 20 kg, or with light dumbbells. Use ramp-up sets to find a load you can press for 8-12 controlled reps with 2-3 left in reserve.

Should beginners test their one-rep max?

No. A one-rep max test adds risk and tells a beginner little, since your strength changes quickly early on. Working with rep ranges and reps in reserve is safer and just as useful.

Is it bad to start with only the bar?

Not at all. The bar lets you learn the pattern with low risk. If it's genuinely easy, you'll add weight within a session or two.

Why do my starting weights feel different each session?

Sleep, stress, food and soreness all change how strong you feel. Use reps in reserve to adjust on the day, and look at your trend over a few weeks, not one session.

Sources

  1. American College of Sports Medicine (2009), Med Sci Sports Exerc - Progression models in resistance training
  2. Zourdos et al. (2016), J Strength Cond Res - RPE scale measuring repetitions in reserve
  3. Schoenfeld et al. (2017), J Strength Cond Res - Low- vs high-load resistance training meta-analysis
  4. Schoenfeld et al. (2021), Sports - Re-examination of the repetition continuum
  5. Grgic et al. (2022), J Sport Health Sci - Training to failure vs non-failure meta-analysis
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog