← Back to blog
Muscle Gain· 5 min read

Should You Bulk or Cut First?

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

Cut first if your main goal is to lose fat, your health markers need work, or you would not tolerate gaining more. Bulk first if you are fairly lean and want size. The popular claim that cutting first makes later muscle gain more efficient is not well supported, so pick the phase you will actually stick to.

There is no single right order. If you carry more fat than you are comfortable with, start with a cut. If you are already lean and your priority is muscle, start with a lean bulk. The common idea that you must get lean first so your body builds muscle better during the bulk has much weaker evidence behind it than most people think.

Where does the cut first rule come from?

The rule rests on a concept called the p-ratio, which is the share of weight change that comes from lean mass rather than fat. The theory says people with more body fat send a bigger share of surplus calories to fat, so you should diet down before you bulk.

In a detailed review at Stronger By Science, Eric Trexler traced this idea back to overfeeding models built mostly on people who did not lift weights. When he pooled individual data from seven resistance training studies, higher starting body fat actually predicted slightly better lean gains, not worse. Fat-free mass gain was unrelated to starting body fat. His summary: there is insufficient evidence that losing fat will improve your later muscle gain.

He also points to studies of college football players. Linemen who started around 21-22% body fat gained as much or more lean mass over training as lean skill players who started under 9%.

When does it make sense to cut first?

Cutting first is still a good choice for many people. The reasons are practical, not about partitioning.

  • Your main goal is fat loss or a health change, such as blood pressure or waist size.
  • You would feel uncomfortable gaining a few more kilos before seeing results.
  • You are new to lifting and carry extra fat. Beginners can often build some muscle while losing fat if protein and training are in place.
  • You plan a long building phase later and want room to gain without ending up far above where you started.

If you cut, keep it controlled. A review of natural bodybuilding prep by Helms and colleagues (2014) recommends losing about 0.5-1% of body weight per week to keep muscle. Faster than that raises the risk of losing lean mass along with fat.

When does it make sense to bulk first?

Bulking first fits people who are already fairly lean, feel small rather than soft, and mainly want to add size and strength. It also suits people who find dieting miserable and would quit a cut within a month.

Keep the bulk lean. A review of off-season nutrition by Iraki and colleagues (2019) suggests a surplus of about 10-20% above maintenance for novice and intermediate lifters, with a target gain of about 0.25-0.5% of body weight per week. Advanced lifters should aim lower.

Will you lose muscle if you cut first?

Not much, if you set the cut up well. A meta-analysis by Murphy and Koehler (2022) found that people lifting in a deficit still gained strength at a similar rate to people at maintenance, although their lean mass gains were smaller. Their analysis suggested keeping the deficit at or below about 500 kcal a day if you want to hold on to muscle.

In practice that means a cut first plan should look like this: a moderate deficit, protein kept high, the same heavy lifts you would do on a bulk, and a slow rate of loss. Done that way, the cut costs you little muscle, and you start the next building phase leaner and with the same strength base. Done badly, with crash dieting and dropped training, it can leave you smaller and weaker than when you started, which is the outcome most people fear when they hear cut first.

Does a big surplus build muscle faster?

Mostly it builds fat faster. In a trial of trained lifters, Helms and colleagues (2023) compared maintenance, a 5% surplus and a 15% surplus over eight weeks. Squat strength and muscle thickness did not differ clearly between groups. Skinfold thickness rose more in the 15% group. The authors concluded that faster weight gain mainly increased fat gain.

This matters for the bulk or cut decision. If you bulk slowly, you gain less fat, and the next cut is shorter. That makes bulking first less of a risk than it sounds.

What about staying at maintenance and doing both?

Body recomposition, losing fat and gaining muscle at roughly the same weight, is a real option. It works best for beginners, people returning after a break, and people with more body fat. Trexler's analysis found that leaner people tended to gain more fat when they gained weight, which fits the idea that recomposition is easier when you start with more fat to use.

The trade-off is speed. Progress on the scale is slow, so you need other markers such as strength, waist measurements and photos to see it.

How do you decide in five minutes?

Answer these questions honestly:

  • Which would you rather see in 12 weeks: a smaller waist or a bigger chest and arms?
  • Would gaining 2-3 kg over three months bother you enough to quit?
  • Do you have health markers your GP wants you to improve?
  • Are you new to lifting or coming back after a long break?

If the smaller waist or health markers win, cut first. If size wins and a few kilos do not bother you, bulk first. If you are new or returning, start at maintenance with a solid program and let your first few months show you what your body does. Either way, the phase you can stick to for 12 weeks or more will beat the theoretically perfect one you abandon.

If you want someone to make the call with you and adjust it each week, that is what 1:1 coaching is for.

Common questions

Is being skinny fat a reason to bulk or cut?

Usually neither extreme. Most people who feel skinny fat do best with a recomposition or a slow lean bulk with heavy focus on lifting and protein. A big cut often leaves them smaller without looking leaner.

How long should each phase last?

Give either phase at least 8-12 weeks so you can see a real trend. Short phases that flip every few weeks tend to produce very little change in either direction.

Does insulin sensitivity mean fatter people should cut first?

The theory is popular, but the evidence in people who lift is mixed. Trexler's review found no clear sign that higher body fat impairs muscle gain in trained populations.

Do women need a different approach?

The same principles apply. Choose the phase that matches your goal and your tolerance for weight change, and use the same slow rates of loss or gain.

Sources

  1. Trexler, Stronger By Science - Should you cut before you bulk? How body-fat levels affect your p-ratio
  2. Helms et al. (2014), Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition - Evidence-based recommendations for natural bodybuilding contest preparation
  3. Iraki et al. (2019), Sports - Nutrition recommendations for bodybuilders in the off-season
  4. Helms et al. (2023), Sports Medicine Open - Effect of small and large energy surpluses on strength, muscle, and skinfold thickness
  5. Murphy and Koehler (2022), Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports - Energy deficiency impairs resistance training gains in lean mass but not strength
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog