← Back to blog
Nutrition· 4 min read

Hardgainer: How to Eat More Without Forcing It

By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist


The short answer

Eat more by making food easier to eat, not by forcing huge plates. Drink some of your calories, since liquid calories trigger weaker appetite compensation. Pick energy-dense foods, eat 4-6 times a day on a schedule, and raise intake by 100-150 kcal at a time until you gain about 0.25-0.5% of body weight per week.

Most hardgainers are not broken. They just eat less than they think, and their appetite shuts the door early. The fix is to make extra calories easy: food that is dense, drinks that add energy without filling you up, and a meal schedule that does not depend on feeling hungry. Raise intake in small steps and let the scale guide you.

Why is it so hard for some people to gain weight?

Appetite and activity both push back when you eat more. A review by Levine (2002) notes that non-exercise activity, the fidgeting, pacing and moving you do without thinking, rises when people overeat. Some people burn a lot of extra calories this way without noticing.

Many people who call themselves hardgainers also eat big on some days and very little on others. The weekly average ends up near maintenance, so the scale does not move. Tracking intake for a week usually shows the gap.

Two quick checks help. First, weigh and log everything for seven days, including drinks and snacks. Second, look at the lowest days as well as the average. Most people find that two or three light days a week cancel out their good ones. Fixing those days is easier than adding a huge amount of food to every day.

How many extra calories does a hardgainer need?

Start with a modest surplus and adjust from results. A review of off-season nutrition by Iraki and colleagues (2019) recommends about 10-20% above maintenance for novice and intermediate lifters, with a target gain of about 0.25-0.5% of body weight per week.

  • Track your normal intake and morning weight for two weeks.
  • Add 10% to your average intake, for example 2,400 kcal becomes about 2,640 kcal.
  • If weight has not risen after two to three weeks, add another 100-150 kcal a day.
  • Repeat until you gain at your target rate.

For a 65 kg lifter, 0.25-0.5% per week is about 0.16-0.33 kg a week. That is slow, but it adds up to roughly 0.7-1.4 kg a month of mostly useful weight.

Do liquid calories really help?

Yes, and the research is clear on the mechanism. In a crossover study by DiMeglio and Mattes (2000), people added the same 1,880 kJ of carbohydrate a day as either soft drink or jelly beans for four weeks. With the jelly beans, they ate less food elsewhere and made up for it almost exactly. With the drink, they did not eat less at all, and their body weight rose.

For someone trying to lose weight, that is a warning. For a hardgainer, it is a tool. Use drinks that also bring protein and nutrients:

  • Full cream milk with meals instead of water.
  • A smoothie of milk, oats, banana, peanut butter and protein powder.
  • Juice with breakfast.
  • A milk-based drink in the evening.

Which foods make eating more easier?

Foods that are quick and easy to eat. In an inpatient trial by Hall and colleagues (2019), adults offered ultra-processed meals ate about 508 kcal a day more than when offered unprocessed meals, and gained 0.9 kg in two weeks. The diets were matched for calories, energy density and macronutrients presented, so the difference came from the type of food rather than the calories on the plate. Softer, quicker to eat foods tend to slip past appetite.

You do not need a diet of junk food to use that effect. Choose less processed foods that are also calorie-dense and easy to eat:

  • Nuts, nut butters and trail mix.
  • Olive oil added to rice, pasta and vegetables.
  • Granola or muesli instead of plain oats.
  • Dried fruit, cheese and full fat yoghurt.
  • White rice, pasta and bread, which are less filling than high fibre options.

Keep plenty of fruit and vegetables in the diet, but do not fill most of your plate with them if you cannot finish your meals.

Cooking methods matter as well. Roasting vegetables in oil, adding cheese to eggs or pasta, and using milk instead of water in oats all raise the energy in a meal without making the portion bigger. These small additions are often easier than eating another full meal.

How should you structure meals if you are never hungry?

Eat on a schedule rather than by appetite. Iraki and colleagues suggest 3-6 meals spread evenly across the day, with protein in each. For a hardgainer, more frequent and smaller meals often feel easier than three huge ones.

  • Set four to five fixed eating times and treat them like appointments.
  • Make breakfast count even if you are not hungry. A smoothie works well.
  • Eat a meal within 1-2 hours after training, when appetite is often higher.
  • Keep a pre-portioned snack in your bag or desk.

Protein still matters. Iraki and colleagues recommend 1.6-2.2 g per kg per day. In an overfeeding trial by Bray and colleagues (2012), people who overate on a very low protein diet gained no lean mass, while those on normal or higher protein gained about 2.9-3.2 kg of it.

How do you keep it going for months?

Variety and routine. Rotate a handful of easy meals you like, and swap them when you get bored rather than skipping meals. Macro-matched meal swaps in the MBM app, launching soon, let you change a meal while keeping macros within about 10%, so a new meal does not mean a smaller one.

If you have a very low appetite, unexplained weight loss, or digestive problems, see your GP before assuming you are just a hardgainer.

Common questions

Will mass gainer shakes help?

They can, since they are liquid calories. A homemade smoothie with milk, oats and protein powder does the same job and lets you control what goes in.

Should I eat junk food to gain weight?

A small amount of easy, energy-dense food is fine. Relying on it heavily tends to push your rate of gain too high and crowd out protein and nutrients.

Does cardio stop a hardgainer from gaining?

Only if you do not eat for it. Keep moderate cardio and walking for health, and add enough food to cover them.

How long until I see the scale move?

Give each increase two to three weeks of consistent eating before you judge it. Water and food volume can hide a real change for the first week or so.

Sources

  1. Iraki et al. (2019), Sports - Nutrition recommendations for bodybuilders in the off-season
  2. DiMeglio and Mattes (2000), International Journal of Obesity - Liquid versus solid carbohydrate: effects on food intake and body weight
  3. Hall et al. (2019), Cell Metabolism - Ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain
  4. Bray et al. (2012), JAMA - Effect of dietary protein content on weight gain, energy expenditure, and body composition during overeating
  5. Levine (2002), Best Practice and Research Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism - Non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT)
Work with Mac

Ready to apply this to your own program?

MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.

Keep reading

← More posts on the MBM blog