Beginner Workout Plan for Men vs Women: Do They Differ?
By Mac Burke, qualified sports nutritionist
The short answer
Men and women don't need different beginner workout plans. A 2020 meta-analysis found similar relative muscle growth between sexes, and women gained relatively more upper-body strength. Both should start with 2-3 full-body sessions a week, 8-12 reps per set and steady load increases. Adjust the plan for your goals, schedule and starting strength instead.
Search for a beginner plan and you'll find blue ones for men and pink ones for women. The muscles, the lifts and the rules of progress are the same. What should change your plan is your goal, your starting strength and how many days you can train. Your gender is a weak reason to change anything.
Do men and women respond differently to strength training?
Less than most people think. A 2020 meta-analysis by Roberts, Nuckols and Krieger compared men and women on the same programs. For muscle growth, 12 outcomes from 10 studies showed no significant difference between sexes. For lower-body strength there was no significant difference either. For upper-body strength, women had a larger relative gain.
A large 2005 study by Hubal and colleagues trained 585 people (342 women and 243 men) for 12 weeks. Men had a slightly greater relative increase in arm muscle size, about 2.5% more. Women had greater relative strength gains. Most striking was how much individuals varied. Size changes ranged from -2% to +59%, regardless of sex.
So the gap between two men, or two women, is often bigger than the gap between the average man and the average woman.
Most of the studies in that meta-analysis used untrained participants, which makes the findings especially relevant to beginners. Start with the same plan, then let your own log show you how you respond.
Should women lift lighter weights to avoid getting bulky?
No. Building muscle is slow for everyone, and nobody adds noticeable size by accident in a few months of beginner training. Very light weights for high reps can still build muscle if you take sets close to failure. A 2017 meta-analysis found muscle growth was similar between low and high loads when sets were hard. But heavy-enough loads build strength faster, which is what most beginners want.
The American College of Sports Medicine recommends novices use loads they can lift for 8-12 reps. That advice is the same for men and women.
In practice, the bigger risk for most beginners of any gender is lifting too light for too long. If you finish a set of 12 and could easily do 8 more, the weight isn't challenging enough to drive much change. Choose a load that makes the last few reps of each set feel hard, with good form.
What does one beginner plan for both look like?
Train full body 3 days a week, alternating two workouts. Do 2-3 sets of 8-12 reps per exercise and stop each set with 1-3 reps in reserve.
- Workout A: goblet squat, dumbbell bench press, seated cable row, Romanian deadlift, plank
- Workout B: leg press, lat pulldown, overhead dumbbell press, hip thrust, side plank
- Progression: when you hit 12 reps on every set, add 2-10% load, as the ACSM recommends
Each workout takes about 45-60 minutes with rest. Rest 2-3 minutes after squats, presses and rows, and about a minute after core work. Pick weights that let you hit 8-12 reps with good form, and write them down. If two people train together on this plan, the only thing that needs to change is the weight on the bar.
How should you adjust the plan for your goals?
Customise by goal, not by gender. Some common tweaks:
- Want more glute and leg development: add a third lower-body exercise, such as walking lunges, to each session.
- Want a bigger chest, back and arms: add 2 sets of curls and triceps pushdowns at the end of each session.
- Want fat loss: keep the same lifting plan and add daily walking. Lifting helps you keep muscle while you lose fat.
- Very short on time: drop to 2 sessions a week and keep all the main lifts.
These are the same choices whoever you are. A man can want strong glutes. A woman can want a stronger bench press.
What actually differs between men and women starting out?
Mostly starting points. On average, men start stronger in absolute terms, especially in the upper body. Many women starting out find upper-body pulling, such as chin-ups, hardest. Use assisted machines, bands or lat pulldowns, and track progress honestly. Given the meta-analysis data on relative upper-body strength gains, expect those lifts to climb.
Life stage matters more than sex. A new mum returning after birth, a man over 40 with a stiff back, or anyone coming off an injury needs a more gradual start. For postpartum training, pelvic health or any injury, check in with your GP or a women's health physio first.
How should you progress the plan over 12 weeks?
Progression is the same for everyone. Keep a weight until you hit the top of the rep range on every set, then add load. The ACSM recommends a 2-10% increase once you can do one or two reps more than your target. Small muscles and upper-body lifts sit at the low end of that range. Big leg lifts can move faster.
- Weeks 1-4: 2 sets per exercise with about 3 reps in reserve. Learn the lifts and settle on your starting weights.
- Weeks 5-8: 3 sets per exercise with 2 reps in reserve. Add load each time you reach 12 reps on every set.
- Weeks 9-12: keep 3 sets and push the main lifts to 1-2 reps in reserve.
Log every session. The Hubal study showed how differently people respond, so the only fair comparison is you against your own numbers from a month ago.
Where should you start this week?
Pick your 2-3 training days, run the A/B plan above for 12 weeks and log every set. If you'd like a plan built around your specific goal and schedule, structured programs are coming to the MBM app, with early access at /app.
Common questions
Will lifting weights make women bulky?
Not as a beginner. Muscle builds slowly for everyone and depends on years of training and eating enough. You control the outcome, since you choose how much you train and eat.
Should men do more upper body than women?
Only if that is their goal. A balanced beginner plan trains the upper and lower body roughly equally. You can add extra sets for areas you want to bring up.
Do women need more reps than men?
No. The 8-12 rep range the ACSM recommends for novices applies to both. Adjust reps for the exercise and your goal, not your gender.
Can men and women train together on the same plan?
Yes. Couples and friends often share a plan and simply use different weights. Each person tracks their own loads and progresses when they beat their own target reps.
Sources
- Roberts, Nuckols & Krieger (2020), J Strength Cond Res - Sex differences in resistance training meta-analysis
- Hubal et al. (2005), Med Sci Sports Exerc - Variability in muscle size and strength gain after resistance training
- Schoenfeld et al. (2017), J Strength Cond Res - Low- vs high-load resistance training meta-analysis
- American College of Sports Medicine (2009), Med Sci Sports Exerc - Progression models in resistance training
Ready to apply this to your own program?
MBM builds 1:1 coaching programs around the exact principles above - weekly check-ins, weekly adjustments, and a plan that fits your life.